Home › Pets

By Robert Johnson•Last Updated April 22, 2025

Comprehensive Guide to Evaluating Popular Dog Foods: Purina, NutriSource, Nulo, Acana, Blue Buffalo, Open Farm, and Sundays

Introduction: Why Choosing the Right Dog Food Matters

Deciding on the best dog food is critical for your pet’s long-term health, energy, and quality of life. With an ever-growing range of brands-each offering unique formulas and nutritional philosophies-pet owners need clear, unbiased information to make informed choices. This guide offers a thorough evaluation of Purina, NutriSource, Nulo, Acana, Blue Buffalo, Open Farm , and provides actionable steps to purchase Sundays Dog Food .

Purina: Widely Available, But Is It Good Dog Food?

Purina is one of the most recognizable names in pet food, offering a spectrum of products from basic grocery store options to premium lines like Pro Plan. Reviewers highlight that while Purina products are easy to find and cover a wide price range, their ingredient quality varies greatly:

Purina Dog Chow has a high carbohydrate content (about 57%) and relies heavily on plant proteins and artificial additives. Its modest nutritional profile suits dogs with robust health or short-term needs, but it is less suitable for pets with specific dietary requirements or sensitivities. Experts rate it at 2.3 out of 5 stars for overall quality [1] .
Purina Pro Plan , often marketed as a premium option, contains more grains than meat and lacks additions like probiotics or omega fatty acids found in higher-end brands. Its protein and fat content is considered average, placing it at the middle of the market [2] .
Some lines, like Purina Dog Chow, list real meat as the first ingredient, and Purina does offer special diets for health needs. However, the use of artificial colors, unnamed meats, and grain-heavy formulas are concerns for those seeking optimal nutrition [5] .

Key Guidance: Purina may be suitable for owners with budget constraints, multiple dogs, or limited access to specialty brands. However, if your dog has sensitivities, allergies, or you want to maximize long-term health, consider upgrading to a more nutritionally robust option.

NutriSource: Holistic Approach, Moderate Price Point

NutriSource is known for emphasizing digestibility, gut health, and inclusion of supplements like probiotics and omega fatty acids. Many formulas are grain-inclusive, but grain-free options are available for sensitive dogs. Owners often report visible improvements in coat quality and digestion when switching from generic brands.

Practical Steps: You can find NutriSource at independent pet retailers and specialty chains. When considering NutriSource, ask your local pet store about specific formulas for puppies, seniors, or dogs with allergies. Evaluate ingredient panels for meat-first recipes and ensure the formula fits your dog’s size and activity level.

Alternative Approaches: If NutriSource is unavailable locally, other holistic brands with similar philosophies include Fromm and Wellness. Always introduce new foods gradually to minimize digestive upset and consult your veterinarian if your dog has a complex medical history.

Nulo: High Meat Content and Functional Nutrition

Nulo has established a reputation for high protein content, low-glycemic ingredients, and the use of fresh meats as primary components. Many recipes are grain-free, making them a popular choice for dogs with sensitivities or owners seeking a diet closer to ancestral nutrition.

Functional ingredients like probiotics, omega-3s, and antioxidants are added to support digestion and immune function. Nulo is often recommended for active dogs, working breeds, or those with higher calorie needs.

How to Access: Nulo is stocked at specialty pet stores and is widely available through major online retailers. When selecting a formula, review the guaranteed analysis to ensure it meets your dog’s protein and fat requirements. If your dog is new to high-protein diets, transition slowly and monitor for changes in stool quality.

Acana: Biologically Appropriate, Premium Ingredients

Acana is recognized for its “biologically appropriate” philosophy-using high-quality meats, fresh regional ingredients, and minimal processing. Recipes typically feature multiple protein sources and limited synthetic additives. Acana avoids cheap fillers and artificial colors, making it appealing for owners seeking a premium, natural option.

Acana’s formulas are generally higher in both protein and fat than most supermarket brands, which can benefit active dogs but may require portion control for less active pets.

Acquiring Acana: Acana is available at independent pet stores and select specialty chains. Check with your local retailer for formula availability, as some varieties may be region-specific. If you have questions about ingredient sourcing or recall history, visit the manufacturer’s official website or contact their customer care team for transparency.

Blue Buffalo: Popular, Accessible, but Mixed Reviews

Blue Buffalo is a widely available brand emphasizing natural ingredients and avoiding poultry by-product meals and artificial preservatives. Their “LifeSource Bits” are a proprietary blend of vitamins and antioxidants intended to support immune health.

However, Blue Buffalo has faced criticism for formula changes, ingredient inconsistencies, and past recalls. Owners report varied experiences-some see improvements in coat and digestion, while others encounter allergies or digestive issues after formula reformulations.

Guidance: To purchase Blue Buffalo, visit major pet chains or grocery stores. If your dog has a sensitive stomach, monitor closely during any formula transition. For the most up-to-date recall information or ingredient details, consult the official Blue Buffalo website or the FDA’s pet food recall database.

Sundays Dog Food: Where and How to Buy

Sundays Dog Food offers air-dried, minimally processed recipes, targeting owners who want a fresh and convenient alternative to kibble or canned diets. The brand focuses on human-grade ingredients and transparency in sourcing.

To buy Sundays Dog Food, visit the official Sundays for Dogs website. The company operates primarily through direct-to-consumer online sales, often using a subscription model. You can:

Go to the Sundays for Dogs official website (search “Sundays Dog Food official site” in your browser).
Browse available formulas and ingredients lists to ensure suitability for your dog’s needs.
Choose a one-time purchase or set up a recurring subscription for ongoing delivery.
Contact customer service via the website for questions about shipping, delivery timelines, or customizations.

If you prefer not to order online, check with local boutique pet stores, though availability may be limited outside major metropolitan areas.

Open Farm: Ethical Sourcing and Transparency

Open Farm distinguishes itself by prioritizing ethical ingredient sourcing, traceability, and environmental sustainability. Each batch can be traced back to its source, and the brand emphasizes non-GMO vegetables, humanely raised meats, and ocean-caught fish.

Open Farm offers grain-free and grain-inclusive options, making it versatile for many dietary needs. Owners often choose Open Farm for dogs with food allergies or when transparency is a top priority.

Steps to Purchase: You can find Open Farm at independent pet retailers and select national chains. To verify sourcing and ingredient lists, visit the Open Farm website and use their batch tracking tool. If your local store does not carry Open Farm, ask about special order options or check for authorized online retailers.

Key Considerations When Choosing Dog Food

When evaluating any dog food brand, consider these factors:

Ingredient Quality: Look for named meat sources and avoid excessive fillers or artificial additives.
Recall History: Research recent product recalls and how the company handled them.
Price vs. Value: While premium foods often cost more, they may reduce veterinary bills and improve your dog’s health in the long run.
Special Needs: Dogs with allergies, chronic health issues, or high activity levels may require specialized formulas.

Consult your veterinarian before making significant dietary changes, especially if your dog is a puppy, senior, or has pre-existing health conditions.

Accessing the Best Nutrition for Your Dog: Step-by-Step Guidance

To ensure you choose and access the best food for your dog:

Identify your dog’s specific nutritional needs based on age, health, activity, and sensitivities.
Research brands and formulas using trusted review sites (e.g., Dog Food Advisor, Consumer Affairs) and official brand websites.
Visit independent pet stores for expert guidance and to compare ingredient labels in person.
For specialty diets or brands not available locally, use verified online retailers or the official brand website to order directly.
Transition to new diets slowly, monitoring your dog’s health and behavior for any adverse reactions.
If uncertain about recalls or formula changes, check the FDA pet food recall database or consult your veterinarian.

Summary and Key Takeaways

Dog food brands differ widely in ingredient quality, nutritional philosophy, and price point. Purina provides basic, affordable options but may not meet optimal health standards for all dogs. NutriSource, Nulo, Acana, and Open Farm offer specialized formulas for owners seeking higher-quality ingredients and fewer additives. Blue Buffalo is popular but has a mixed track record regarding consistency. Sundays Dog Food is a direct-to-consumer option for those prioritizing convenience and whole-food nutrition. Always research, consult professionals, and transition diets carefully to support your dog’s wellbeing.